Since this seems to be getting a lot of play recently on the blog, this may now require its own post.
Any chance we can get a consensus as to which states are southern? In tying this somehow to our class, we have dealt with two border states: Virginia and Maryland. Maryland, through Frederick Douglass, showing that there was quite a presence of slavery. Virginia, through Poe, showing that the southern aristocracy and the slavery also heavily influenced his writing.
The definites seem to be North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Kentucky, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana and Arkansas.
Likely southern: Virginia, Texas, West Virginia, Florida
Fringe candidates: Maryland, Oklahoma, Missouri
If it was up to me, you have to throw Virginia and Texas in there. The South wouldn’t be the South if it wasn’t for Virginia. Also, Virginia WAS the Confederacy. Virginia is like the grandfather to the entire South. East Texas, because it is so southern, has to be in there. I don’t care what western or northern Texas is like, it’s a dang southern state.
In the case of West Virginia, just know that rednecks and white trash do not make a state southern! South Florida is WAY too northern (if that makes sense) to get the nod as southern.
Alright, so who ya got?